Article cover about negative equity in car deals; shows a worried person, a laptop with a chart, and a car icon with a magnifying glass.

Negative Equity Is Breaking the New-Car Deal. Here’s How Dealers Can Fix It.

Nearly one in three trade-ins walking onto a dealer’s lot right now is underwater. That’s according to the latest data from Edmunds, and it’s a problem every desk manager in the country is fighting.

What Edmunds' Q2 Data Actually Shows

According to Edmunds’ Q2 2026 vehicle transaction data, 29.6% of trade-ins toward new-vehicle purchases had negative equity in the second quarter. That’s the highest Q2 figure since 2020. The dollar amounts are just as telling: the average negative equity balance hit $6,884, a record for a second quarter, and it’s dragging monthly payments and interest costs to levels the industry hasn’t seen before.

The average monthly payment on a new-vehicle loan with negative equity on the trade-in reached $944 in Q2 — $167 more than the industry average of $777. Roll that negative equity into a new loan and, on average, a buyer is now projected to pay $16,270 in interest over the life of that loan, nearly $6,500 more than a typical new-vehicle buyer pays.

Maybe the most uncomfortable finding: this isn’t limited to vehicles that depreciate fast. Edmunds’ analysis of the models carrying the highest volumes of negative equity found popular trucks and SUVs including the Chevrolet Silverado, Ford F-150, and Ram 1500 sitting alongside traditional resale-value winners like the Toyota Camry and Honda CR-V. As Edmunds’ director of insights put it, when historically safe residual-value bets are showing up underwater, it’s a financing problem, not a vehicle-choice problem.

Why So Many Trade-Ins Are Upside Down

The roots of this go back to the chip and vehicle shortages in 2021 caused by Covid. Inventory was scarce, incentives disappeared, and buyers routinely paid at or above MSRP just to get a vehicle. Edmunds notes the average trade-in age with negative equity now sits at a Q2 record of 4.0 years which lines up almost exactly with vehicles bought during that shortage.

Here’s the part that trips people up: it’s not really about depreciation curves. It’s about the gap between what someone paid two or three years ago and what the same vehicle sells for today, now that supply has normalized. Because of the return of OEM incentives and discounting from MSRP, a truck that sold for $60,000 during the shortage might sell for $48,000 today. The customer hasn’t come close to paying their loan down to $48,000 yet, so on paper, they’re upside down on a vehicle that’s actually holding its value reasonably well by historical standards.

Layer on a second trend: shrinking down payments. Fewer buyers are putting the traditional 5–10% down, which used to absorb taxes, fees, and the first chunk of depreciation. Skip that cushion, and the next trade-in starts underwater from day one. The lack of low or incentivized rates, combined with paying more during the shortage, and rising MSRPs caused buyers to stretch lending terms to make the payment affordable. That created a slow-motion equity trap: lower payment today, bigger hole to climb out of tomorrow.

The Affordability Squeeze Every Shopper Feels

This is where negative equity stops being a balance-sheet issue and becomes an affordability issue. A shopper with equity in their trade can roll that value forward and stretch into more car, the same way a homeowner uses equity to move up. A shopper with negative equity does the opposite: they’re financing their old debt and a new vehicle at the same time, which pushes the payment up before a single option or upgrade even enters the conversation.

Edmunds’ own advice for consumers is to check their loan payoff against their vehicle’s current trade-in value before shopping, so they know upfront whether they’re underwater. That’s a reasonable first step for a shopper. It does nothing to help the dealer actually structure a deal once that customer is standing at the desk with negative equity, a payment target they can’t move off of, and a credit profile that may or may not cooperate.

That’s the gap. And it’s a primary gap Informativ built SmartPencil to close.

Why the Old Way of Solving This Doesn't Scale

Structuring a deal with negative equity has always required specialized knowledge: current loan-to-value (LTV) limits by lender, which programs stack with which incentives, and which banks will actually buy a deal at a given risk profile. A common LTV ceiling sits around 120% of a vehicle’s book-out value, meaning a desk manager has to know, in the moment, exactly how much room that gives them to bury negative equity before a lender kicks the deal back. We’re also seeing lenders manage LTV like a grid, where more variables are taken into consideration for how much risk they’ll take on (term, tier, vehicle mileage, etc.)

When that knowledge lives in one person’s head or in a binder, the process breaks down fast. A desk manager who’s mastered four or five lender programs can usually make those deals work. The moment the customer’s profile falls outside that narrow lane, or the exact vehicle-and-bank combination they know isn’t available, they’re improvising. Deals get shotgunned to multiple lenders hoping something sticks. Often, the first lender to respond gets the deal. Sometimes the submissions that don’t get booked create a ripple effect that may strain the dealer-lender relationship.  What should take a few minutes is now eatting up to 30 minutes and  is impacting dealer’s profit. Plus, lender rules, rates, and incentive programs change monthly, so yesterday’s shortcut may not even apply today.

There’s also a persistent myth in this business: that a customer with negative equity needs a cheaper car. It’s often the opposite. Since lenders base approvals on a percentage above a vehicle’s value, a more expensive vehicle can actually generate more room to absorb negative equity. Knowing when and how to move a customer up in trim or model isn’t guesswork. It’s math. And it’s math that legacy desking tools were never built to run.

How SmartPencil Was Built for Exactly This Moment

SmartPencil takes the lender rules, LTV thresholds, incentive programs, and inventory data that used to live in a desk manager’s head, or nowhere at all, and puts them in front of every user, on every deal, automatically.

SmartPencil keeps every structure inside lender guardrails. It applies real LTV constraints as a deal is built, flagging the moment a structure exceeds a lender’s threshold instead of letting it get submitted and declined. Desk managers see instantly which lenders a deal will clear and which ones it won’t. That problem used to only surface after a decline came back.

SmartPencil surfaces incentive stacks a person would otherwise have to hunt for. Trade assistance, bonus cash, loyalty credits, military and first-responder programs, dealer discounts, select-market cash: SmartPencil pulls the full available stack for a specific vehicle and trim rather than requiring a desk manager to dig through emails and rate sheets. In a market where OEM incentives are becoming aggressive again after several lean years, that visibility is often the difference between a deal that works and one that doesn’t.

SmartPencil compares lease, loan, and term instantly. Balancing affordability isn’t one lever, it’s several. SmartPencil lets a desk manager compare lease against loan, test a longer term against a shorter one, and see the profit and payment impact of each in real time, rather than rebuilding the deal from scratch every time a customer says no. The most effective users of SmartPencil no longer have to negotiate price. They negotiate down payment and terms, maximize rebates and incentives, and find where the back-end profit can be maximized.

SmartPencil points to the right vehicle, not just the right rate. Through its recommendation engine, SmartPencil looks beyond the vehicle a customer walked in on and surfaces other inventory that better fits the deal, whether that means a different trim with more LTV room, an older unit the dealer needs to move, or a vehicle that better matches the customer’s actual payment tolerance. That single capability turns “I don’t think this deal works” into “here are three ways it might.”

SmartPencil finds profit a human would miss. Because SmartPencil evaluates lender rules, markup structures, and bank splits together, not in isolation, it surfaces lender combinations a desk manager may not have picked on their own – This includes deals that may have a lower payments, yet higher dealer profit.A Kentucky dealership recently saw this first-hand when SmartPencil presented a bank they didn’t even consider, which made the dealer over $1,000 additional profit and gave the customer a $15 lower monthky  payment than the original bank of choice.

The Real Payoff: Desk Consistency and Profitability

The deeper value isn’t any single feature; it’s what SmartPencil does to consistency across an entire desk.

Every dealership has a wide range of desk manager experience, and turnover in the role is high. A tenured A-player might know five lender programs by heart A newer manager might know one or two. Historically, that gap in institutional knowledge directly determined which deals got done and which got walked. SmartPencil closes that gap by putting  your entire arsenal of lender data, LTV match, and incentive visibility in front of every user consistently, regardless of tenure, so a deal’s outcome depends less on who happens to be at the desk that day.

That consistency shows up directly in profitability. Dealers ultimately track three numbers: total units sold, gross profit per deal, and close rate. Out of every 100 customers who walk in, some can’t be financed no matter what, and some are easy approvals regardless of who’s working the deal. The real opportunity sits with the customers in the middle, the ones who can buy a car if the structure is right. SmartPencil is built specifically for that middle group: it identifies which of those marginal customers can actually be financed, which lender and structure gets them there, and which vehicle makes the math work. It turns deals that used to walk into deals that get funded.

With negative equity at record levels and affordability tighter than ever, that middle group of customers is only getting bigger. The dealers who can consistently structure profitable, compliant deals, not just the easy approvals, are the ones who will keep closing more car deals, more consistently, no matter who’s sitting at the desk.

SmartPencil shows your desk which lender, which structure, and which vehicle makes the deal work before anyone sits down. See how SmartPencil works.

*Data source: [Edmunds, “Q2 New-Vehicle Purchases with Negative Equity Trade-Ins Hit Record Monthly Payments and Interest Costs,” July 16, 2026.](https://www.edmunds.com/industry/press/q2-new-vehicle-purchases-with-negative-equity-trade-ins-hit-record-monthly-payments-and-interest-costs-edmunds-reports.html)*